Question
In an essay of a minimum of 1,000 words, please address this question:

With regards to the play Othello, poet W. H. Auden (1907–1973) famously remarked of Desdemona, “Everybody must pity Desdemona, but I cannot bring myself to like her.” Carefully evaluate this statement by examining Desdemona’s character. You can explore issues of gender, gender roles, social constraints on gender, and the like. Feel free to include other women depicted in the play as part of your discussion, if needed. If you find Auden’s statement either inaccurate or incomplete, specifically describe why you feel that Desdemona is simply someone to be pitied and nothing more.

In addition to using specific quotes from the story or stories, you should utilize at least one additional outside, credible source.
Essays must be in MLA format.
Solution Preview

These solutions may offer step-by-step problem-solving explanations or good writing examples that include modern styles of formatting and construction of bibliographies out of text citations and references.
Students may use these solutions for personal skill-building and practice.
Unethical use is strictly forbidden.

Desdemona was an aristocratic woman who believed that she should gain a greater role in her personal affairs due to her social status. During Elizabethan times, women were expected to fill a subordinate role to the men in their lives (their father and/or husband). As a result, Desdemona was considered to be in violation of the social mores of the time when she spoke out for greater self-determination in her own affairs due to her mad love for Othello.
This is only a preview of the solution.
Please use the purchase button to see the entire solution.
By purchasing this solution you'll be able to access the following files:
Solution.docx
Purchase Solution
$22.50
Google Pay
Amazon
Paypal
Mastercard
Visacard
Discover
Amex
View Available Literature Tutors 529 tutors matched
ionut
Ionut
(ionut)
Hi! MSc Applied Informatics & Computer Science Engineer. Practical experience in many CS & IT branches.Research work & homework
5/5 (5,654+ sessions)
2 hours avg response
Leo
(Leo)
Hi! I have been a professor in New York and taught in a math department and in an applied math department.
4.9/5 (5,652+ sessions)
2 hours avg response
Pranay
(math1983)
Ph.D. in mathematics and working as an Assistant Professor in University. I can provide help in mathematics, statistics and allied areas.
4.6/5 (5,512+ sessions)
1 hour avg response

Similar Homework Solutions

8.1.0PHP Version808msRequest Duration45MBMemory UsageGET college-homework-library/{category}/{subject}/{id}Route
    • Booting (502ms)time
    • Application (306ms)time
    • 1 x Booting (62.09%)
      502ms
      1 x Application (37.91%)
      306ms
      • Illuminate\Routing\Events\Routing (1.45ms)
      • Illuminate\Routing\Events\RouteMatched (594μs)
      • Illuminate\Foundation\Events\LocaleUpdated (5.45ms)
      • eloquent.booting: App\Models\HomeworkLibrary\HomeworkLibrary (222μs)
      • eloquent.booted: App\Models\HomeworkLibrary\HomeworkLibrary (195μs)
      • Illuminate\Database\Events\ConnectionEstablished (920μs)
      • Illuminate\Database\Events\StatementPrepared (8.76ms)
      • Illuminate\Database\Events\QueryExecuted (2.01ms)
      • eloquent.retrieved: App\Models\HomeworkLibrary\HomeworkLibrary (145μs)
      • eloquent.booting: App\Models\Subject (129μs)
      • eloquent.booted: App\Models\Subject (56μs)
      • Illuminate\Database\Events\StatementPrepared (2.26ms)
      • Illuminate\Database\Events\QueryExecuted (1.07ms)
      • eloquent.retrieved: App\Models\Subject (252μs)
      • eloquent.booting: App\Models\HomeworkLibrary\HomeworkLibraryFile (158μs)
      • eloquent.booted: App\Models\HomeworkLibrary\HomeworkLibraryFile (54μs)
      • Illuminate\Database\Events\StatementPrepared (633μs)
      • Illuminate\Database\Events\QueryExecuted (801μs)
      • eloquent.retrieved: App\Models\HomeworkLibrary\HomeworkLibraryFile (86μs)
      • eloquent.retrieved: App\Models\HomeworkLibrary\HomeworkLibraryFile (18μs)
      • eloquent.retrieved: App\Models\HomeworkLibrary\HomeworkLibraryFile (11μs)
      • eloquent.booting: App\Models\SubjectCat (350μs)
      • eloquent.booted: App\Models\SubjectCat (54μs)
      • Illuminate\Database\Events\StatementPrepared (1.05ms)
      • Illuminate\Database\Events\QueryExecuted (922μs)
      • eloquent.retrieved: App\Models\SubjectCat (193μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (37.38ms)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheMissed (516μs)
      • Illuminate\Database\Events\StatementPrepared (9.96ms)
      • Illuminate\Database\Events\QueryExecuted (7.61ms)
      • eloquent.retrieved: App\Models\HomeworkLibrary\HomeworkLibrary (194μs)
      • eloquent.retrieved: App\Models\HomeworkLibrary\HomeworkLibrary (26μs)
      • eloquent.retrieved: App\Models\HomeworkLibrary\HomeworkLibrary (13μs)
      • eloquent.retrieved: App\Models\HomeworkLibrary\HomeworkLibrary (11μs)
      • eloquent.retrieved: App\Models\HomeworkLibrary\HomeworkLibrary (11μs)
      • eloquent.retrieved: App\Models\HomeworkLibrary\HomeworkLibrary (12μs)
      • Illuminate\Database\Events\StatementPrepared (772μs)
      • Illuminate\Database\Events\QueryExecuted (1.04ms)
      • eloquent.retrieved: App\Models\Subject (157μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\KeyWritten (1.22ms)
      • Illuminate\Database\Events\StatementPrepared (8.06ms)
      • Illuminate\Database\Events\QueryExecuted (1.36ms)
      • Illuminate\Database\Events\StatementPrepared (1.18ms)
      • Illuminate\Database\Events\QueryExecuted (5.66ms)
      • Illuminate\Database\Events\StatementPrepared (807μs)
      • Illuminate\Database\Events\QueryExecuted (2.38ms)
      • eloquent.retrieved: App\Models\HomeworkLibrary\HomeworkLibraryFile (79μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (909μs)
      • creating: homework.show (366μs)
      • composing: homework.show (452μs)
      • creating: components.breadcrumbs (487μs)
      • composing: components.breadcrumbs (167μs)
      • Illuminate\Database\Events\StatementPrepared (1.9ms)
      • Illuminate\Database\Events\QueryExecuted (805μs)
      • eloquent.retrieved: App\Models\SubjectCat (98μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (6.65ms)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (211μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (6.33ms)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (339μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (213μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (400μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (483μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (185μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (669μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (399μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (450μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (197μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (186μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (436μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (384μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (196μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (195μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (213μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (464μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (202μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (326μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (712μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (217μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (265μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (200μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (334μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (432μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (1.23ms)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (320μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (2.8ms)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (2.07ms)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (222μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (211μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (299μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (212μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (188μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (225μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (163μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (304μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (264μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (483μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (275μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (204μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (173μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (1.84ms)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (771μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (495μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (337μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (310μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (300μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (598μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (3.73ms)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (852μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (12.19ms)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (499μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (333μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (295μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (194μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (407μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (1.81ms)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (938μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (551μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (356μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (569μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (331μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (179μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (186μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (381μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (203μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (169μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (311μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (306μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (189μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (153μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (174μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (151μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (1.04ms)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (675μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (372μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (8.64ms)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (626μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (222μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (403μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (290μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (215μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (177μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (207μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (254μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (226μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (355μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (310μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (575μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (810μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (541μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (297μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (170μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (194μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (164μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (249μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (221μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (357μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (272μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (1.6ms)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (397μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (377μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (203μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (216μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (266μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (324μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (367μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (213μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (1.7ms)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (226μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (276μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (1.29ms)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (206μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (264μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (169μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (382μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (271μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (215μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (163μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (298μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (169μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (449μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (301μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (273μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (452μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (411μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (706μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (352μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (152μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (386μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (352μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (198μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (157μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (173μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (156μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (450μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (188μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (200μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (245μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (188μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (183μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (344μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (353μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (407μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (143μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (164μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (278μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (266μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (178μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (189μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (161μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (192μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (337μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (159μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (175μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (192μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (116μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (123μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (243μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (377μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (202μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (360μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (321μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (310μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (388μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (499μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (239μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (268μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (172μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (287μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (170μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (266μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (217μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (395μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (178μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (304μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (174μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (200μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (160μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (448μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (204μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (331μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (192μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (482μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (164μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (185μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (174μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (150μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (103μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (221μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (215μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (178μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (242μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (357μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (187μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (205μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (649μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (352μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (196μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (368μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (224μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (513μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (412μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (317μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (453μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (4.79ms)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (272μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (236μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (177μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (194μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (162μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (1.43ms)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (170μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (192μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (485μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (7.79ms)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (209μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (202μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (155μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (178μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (155μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (176μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (231μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (198μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (320μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (420μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (342μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (239μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (461μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (351μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (224μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (604μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (237μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (472μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (312μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (1.69ms)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (217μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (212μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (180μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (701μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (712μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (185μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (285μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (184μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (388μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (296μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (414μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (239μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (359μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (199μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (427μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (455μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (211μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (435μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (173μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (248μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (167μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (187μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (159μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (189μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (156μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (260μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (180μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (251μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (187μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (201μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (168μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (242μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (355μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (423μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (346μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (316μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (166μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (283μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (165μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (297μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (220μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (299μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (220μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (297μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (180μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (198μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (218μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (192μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (457μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (1.28ms)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (202μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (456μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (255μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (253μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (163μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (199μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (166μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (233μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (171μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (192μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (322μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (205μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (165μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (187μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (698μs)
      • creating: site.layouts.app (1.01ms)
      • composing: site.layouts.app (53μs)
      • creating: components.canonical (927μs)
      • composing: components.canonical (238μs)
      • creating: components.open-graph (283μs)
      • composing: components.open-graph (103μs)
      • creating: site.headers.header (653μs)
      • composing: site.headers.header (90μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (1.8ms)
      • creating: components.footer (104μs)
      • composing: components.footer (169μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (12.04ms)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (3.94ms)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (330μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (198μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (235μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (189μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (198μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (305μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (331μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (205μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (188μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (192μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (198μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (195μs)
      • creating: components.forms.contact-us (600μs)
      • composing: components.forms.contact-us (267μs)
      • creating: components.forms.get-started (370μs)
      • composing: components.forms.get-started (110μs)
      • creating: components.forms.free-tool-download (164μs)
      • composing: components.forms.free-tool-download (131μs)
      • creating: components.forms.claim-free-worksheet (545μs)
      • composing: components.forms.claim-free-worksheet (76μs)
      • creating: components.forms.tutor-subscription-waitlist (153μs)
      • composing: components.forms.tutor-subscription-waitlist (75μs)
      • creating: components.forms.tutor-subscription-join (134μs)
      • composing: components.forms.tutor-subscription-join (7.45ms)
      • creating: components.forms.tutor-support (244μs)
      • composing: components.forms.tutor-support (115μs)
      • 321 x Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (26.23%)
        212ms
        10 x Illuminate\Database\Events\StatementPrepared (4.38%)
        35.38ms
        10 x Illuminate\Database\Events\QueryExecuted (2.92%)
        23.64ms
        1 x composing: components.forms.tutor-subscription-join (0.92%)
        7.45ms
        1 x Illuminate\Foundation\Events\LocaleUpdated (0.67%)
        5.45ms
        1 x Illuminate\Routing\Events\Routing (0.18%)
        1.45ms
        1 x Illuminate\Cache\Events\KeyWritten (0.15%)
        1.22ms
        1 x creating: site.layouts.app (0.12%)
        1.01ms
        1 x creating: components.canonical (0.11%)
        927μs
        1 x Illuminate\Database\Events\ConnectionEstablished (0.11%)
        920μs
        1 x creating: site.headers.header (0.08%)
        653μs
        1 x creating: components.forms.contact-us (0.07%)
        600μs
        1 x Illuminate\Routing\Events\RouteMatched (0.07%)
        594μs
        1 x creating: components.forms.claim-free-worksheet (0.07%)
        545μs
        1 x Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheMissed (0.06%)
        516μs
        1 x creating: components.breadcrumbs (0.06%)
        487μs
        1 x composing: homework.show (0.06%)
        452μs
        7 x eloquent.retrieved: App\Models\HomeworkLibrary\HomeworkLibrary (0.05%)
        412μs
        2 x eloquent.retrieved: App\Models\Subject (0.05%)
        409μs
        1 x creating: components.forms.get-started (0.05%)
        370μs
        1 x creating: homework.show (0.05%)
        366μs
        1 x eloquent.booting: App\Models\SubjectCat (0.04%)
        350μs
        2 x eloquent.retrieved: App\Models\SubjectCat (0.04%)
        291μs
        1 x creating: components.open-graph (0.04%)
        283μs
        1 x composing: components.forms.contact-us (0.03%)
        267μs
        1 x creating: components.forms.tutor-support (0.03%)
        244μs
        1 x composing: components.canonical (0.03%)
        238μs
        1 x eloquent.booting: App\Models\HomeworkLibrary\HomeworkLibrary (0.03%)
        222μs
        1 x eloquent.booted: App\Models\HomeworkLibrary\HomeworkLibrary (0.02%)
        195μs
        4 x eloquent.retrieved: App\Models\HomeworkLibrary\HomeworkLibraryFile (0.02%)
        194μs
        1 x composing: components.footer (0.02%)
        169μs
        1 x composing: components.breadcrumbs (0.02%)
        167μs
        1 x creating: components.forms.free-tool-download (0.02%)
        164μs
        1 x eloquent.booting: App\Models\HomeworkLibrary\HomeworkLibraryFile (0.02%)
        158μs
        1 x creating: components.forms.tutor-subscription-waitlist (0.02%)
        153μs
        1 x creating: components.forms.tutor-subscription-join (0.02%)
        134μs
        1 x composing: components.forms.free-tool-download (0.02%)
        131μs
        1 x eloquent.booting: App\Models\Subject (0.02%)
        129μs
        1 x composing: components.forms.tutor-support (0.01%)
        115μs
        1 x composing: components.forms.get-started (0.01%)
        110μs
        1 x creating: components.footer (0.01%)
        104μs
        1 x composing: components.open-graph (0.01%)
        103μs
        1 x composing: site.headers.header (0.01%)
        90μs
        1 x composing: components.forms.claim-free-worksheet (0.01%)
        76μs
        1 x composing: components.forms.tutor-subscription-waitlist (0.01%)
        75μs
        1 x eloquent.booted: App\Models\Subject (0.01%)
        56μs
        1 x eloquent.booted: App\Models\HomeworkLibrary\HomeworkLibraryFile (0.01%)
        54μs
        1 x eloquent.booted: App\Models\SubjectCat (0.01%)
        54μs
        1 x composing: site.layouts.app (0.01%)
        53μs
      14 templates were rendered
      • 1x homework.showshow.blade.phpblade
      • 1x components.breadcrumbsbreadcrumbs.blade.phpblade
      • 1x site.layouts.appapp.blade.phpblade
      • 1x components.canonicalcanonical.blade.phpblade
      • 1x components.open-graphopen-graph.blade.phpblade
      • 1x site.headers.headerheader.blade.phpblade
      • 1x components.footerfooter.blade.phpblade
      • 1x components.forms.contact-uscontact-us.blade.phpblade
      • 1x components.forms.get-startedget-started.blade.phpblade
      • 1x components.forms.free-tool-downloadfree-tool-download.blade.phpblade
      • 1x components.forms.claim-free-worksheetclaim-free-worksheet.blade.phpblade
      • 1x components.forms.tutor-subscription-waitlisttutor-subscription-waitlist.blade.phpblade
      • 1x components.forms.tutor-subscription-jointutor-subscription-join.blade.phpblade
      • 1x components.forms.tutor-supporttutor-support.blade.phpblade
      uri
      GET college-homework-library/{category}/{subject}/{id}
      middleware
      web, utm.parameters
      controller
      App\Http\Controllers\HomeworkLibraryController@show
      namespace
      where
      as
      homework.show
      file
      app/Http/Controllers/HomeworkLibraryController.php:79-176
      10 statements were executed, 4 of which were duplicates, 6 unique. Show only duplicated34.4ms
      • Connection Establishedtwenty4_siteHomeworkLibraryController.php#91
        Backtrace
        • 13. app/Http/Controllers/HomeworkLibraryController.php:91
        • 14. vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Routing/Controller.php:54
        • 15. vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Routing/ControllerDispatcher.php:43
        • 16. vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Routing/Route.php:260
        • 17. vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Routing/Route.php:205
      • select * from `solutionslibrary` where `status` = 'published' and `price` > 0 and `solutionslibrary`.`id` = '2982' limit 1
        8.12mstwenty4_siteHomeworkLibraryController.php#97
        Bindings
        • 0: published
        • 1: 0
        • 2: 2982
        Backtrace
        • 16. app/Http/Controllers/HomeworkLibraryController.php:97
        • 17. vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Routing/Controller.php:54
        • 18. vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Routing/ControllerDispatcher.php:43
        • 19. vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Routing/Route.php:260
        • 20. vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Routing/Route.php:205
      • select * from `subjects` where `subjects`.`id` in (104)
        1.08mstwenty4_siteHomeworkLibraryController.php#97
        Backtrace
        • 21. app/Http/Controllers/HomeworkLibraryController.php:97
        • 22. vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Routing/Controller.php:54
        • 23. vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Routing/ControllerDispatcher.php:43
        • 24. vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Routing/Route.php:260
        • 25. vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Routing/Route.php:205
      • select * from `solutionslibrary_files` where `solutionslibrary_files`.`solutionlib_id` in (2982)
        820μstwenty4_siteHomeworkLibraryController.php#97
        Backtrace
        • 21. app/Http/Controllers/HomeworkLibraryController.php:97
        • 22. vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Routing/Controller.php:54
        • 23. vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Routing/ControllerDispatcher.php:43
        • 24. vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Routing/Route.php:260
        • 25. vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Routing/Route.php:205
      • select * from `subject_cats` where `subject_cats`.`id` = 43 limit 1
        1.19mstwenty4_siteHomeworkLibrary.php#201
        Bindings
        • 0: 43
        Backtrace
        • 20. app/Models/HomeworkLibrary/HomeworkLibrary.php:201
        • 26. app/Http/Controllers/HomeworkLibraryController.php:105
        • 27. vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Routing/Controller.php:54
        • 28. vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Routing/ControllerDispatcher.php:43
        • 29. vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Routing/Route.php:260
      • select * from `solutionslibrary` where `id` <> 2982 and `subject` = 104 and `status` = 'published' and `price` > 0 order by RAND() limit 6
        6.37mstwenty4_siteHomeworkLibraryRepository.php#30
        Bindings
        • 0: 2982
        • 1: 104
        • 2: published
        • 3: 0
        Backtrace
        • 14. app/Repositories/HomeworkLibraryRepository.php:30
        • 15. vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Cache/Repository.php:397
        • 16. vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Cache/CacheManager.php:419
        • 18. app/Repositories/HomeworkLibraryRepository.php:39
        • 19. app/Http/Controllers/HomeworkLibraryController.php:139
      • select * from `subjects` where `subjects`.`id` in (104)
        1.13mstwenty4_siteHomeworkLibraryRepository.php#30
        Backtrace
        • 19. app/Repositories/HomeworkLibraryRepository.php:30
        • 20. vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Cache/Repository.php:397
        • 21. vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Cache/CacheManager.php:419
        • 23. app/Repositories/HomeworkLibraryRepository.php:39
        • 24. app/Http/Controllers/HomeworkLibraryController.php:139
      • select * from `solutionslibrary_files` where `solutionslibrary_files`.`solutionlib_id` = 2982 and `solutionslibrary_files`.`solutionlib_id` is not null and `publish` = 'question' order by `order` asc, `id` asc
        7.06mstwenty4_siteHomeworkLibrary.php#260
        Bindings
        • 0: 2982
        • 1: question
        Backtrace
        • 15. app/Models/HomeworkLibrary/HomeworkLibrary.php:260
        • 16. app/Transformers/HomeworkLibrary/HomeworkLibraryTransformer.php:58
        • 19. vendor/league/fractal/src/TransformerAbstract.php:128
        • 20. vendor/league/fractal/src/TransformerAbstract.php:107
        • 21. vendor/league/fractal/src/Scope.php:383
      • select * from `solutionslibrary_files` where `solutionslibrary_files`.`solutionlib_id` = 2982 and `solutionslibrary_files`.`solutionlib_id` is not null and `publish` = 'teaser' order by `order` asc, `id` asc
        5.45mstwenty4_siteHomeworkLibrary.php#260
        Bindings
        • 0: 2982
        • 1: teaser
        Backtrace
        • 15. app/Models/HomeworkLibrary/HomeworkLibrary.php:260
        • 16. app/Transformers/HomeworkLibrary/HomeworkLibraryTransformer.php:69
        • 19. vendor/league/fractal/src/TransformerAbstract.php:128
        • 20. vendor/league/fractal/src/TransformerAbstract.php:107
        • 21. vendor/league/fractal/src/Scope.php:383
      • select * from `solutionslibrary_files` where `solutionslibrary_files`.`solutionlib_id` = 2982 and `solutionslibrary_files`.`solutionlib_id` is not null and `publish` = 'solution' order by `order` asc, `id` asc
        1.79mstwenty4_siteHomeworkLibrary.php#260
        Bindings
        • 0: 2982
        • 1: solution
        Backtrace
        • 15. app/Models/HomeworkLibrary/HomeworkLibrary.php:260
        • 16. app/Transformers/HomeworkLibrary/HomeworkLibraryTransformer.php:80
        • 19. vendor/league/fractal/src/TransformerAbstract.php:128
        • 20. vendor/league/fractal/src/TransformerAbstract.php:107
        • 21. vendor/league/fractal/src/Scope.php:383
      • select * from `subject_cats` where `subject_cats`.`id` = 43 limit 1
        1.39mstwenty4_siteHomeworkLibrary.php#201
        Bindings
        • 0: 43
        Backtrace
        • 20. app/Models/HomeworkLibrary/HomeworkLibrary.php:201
        • 32. vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Filesystem/Filesystem.php:110
        • 33. vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/View/Engines/PhpEngine.php:58
        • 34. vendor/livewire/livewire/src/ComponentConcerns/RendersLivewireComponents.php:69
        • 35. vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/View/Engines/CompilerEngine.php:70
      App\Models\HomeworkLibrary\HomeworkLibrary
      7HomeworkLibrary.php
      App\Models\HomeworkLibrary\HomeworkLibraryFile
      4HomeworkLibraryFile.php
      App\Models\Subject
      2Subject.php
      App\Models\SubjectCat
      2SubjectCat.php
          _token
          jvAteRegpFLxdSG4mXy2Doxw3IRxHOrlhU9O2Uod
          utm_source
          direct
          redirectUrl
          /college-homework-library/Literature/Literature-Analysis/2982
          _previous
          array:1 [ "url" => "https://staging.dev.24houranswers.com/college-homework-library/Literature/Lite...
          _flash
          array:2 [ "old" => [] "new" => [] ]
          PHPDEBUGBAR_STACK_DATA
          []
          path_info
          /college-homework-library/Literature/Literature-Analysis/2982
          status_code
          200
          
          status_text
          OK
          format
          html
          content_type
          text/html; charset=UTF-8
          request_query
          []
          
          request_request
          []
          
          request_headers
          0 of 0
          array:21 [ "priority" => array:1 [ 0 => "u=0, i" ] "accept-encoding" => array:1 [ 0 => "gzip, deflate, br, zstd" ] "sec-fetch-dest" => array:1 [ 0 => "document" ] "sec-fetch-user" => array:1 [ 0 => "?1" ] "sec-fetch-mode" => array:1 [ 0 => "navigate" ] "sec-fetch-site" => array:1 [ 0 => "none" ] "accept" => array:1 [ 0 => "text/html,application/xhtml+xml,application/xml;q=0.9,image/avif,image/webp,image/apng,*/*;q=0.8,application/signed-exchange;v=b3;q=0.7" ] "user-agent" => array:1 [ 0 => "Mozilla/5.0 AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko; compatible; ClaudeBot/1.0; +claudebot@anthropic.com)" ] "upgrade-insecure-requests" => array:1 [ 0 => "1" ] "sec-ch-ua-platform" => array:1 [ 0 => ""Windows"" ] "sec-ch-ua-mobile" => array:1 [ 0 => "?0" ] "sec-ch-ua" => array:1 [ 0 => ""HeadlessChrome";v="129", "Not=A?Brand";v="8", "Chromium";v="129"" ] "cache-control" => array:1 [ 0 => "no-cache" ] "pragma" => array:1 [ 0 => "no-cache" ] "x-amzn-trace-id" => array:1 [ 0 => "Root=1-67fc8d73-39467b1019761f2f6e2110e5" ] "host" => array:1 [ 0 => "staging.dev.24houranswers.com" ] "x-forwarded-port" => array:1 [ 0 => "443" ] "x-forwarded-proto" => array:1 [ 0 => "https" ] "x-forwarded-for" => array:1 [ 0 => "3.22.234.133" ] "content-length" => array:1 [ 0 => "" ] "content-type" => array:1 [ 0 => "" ] ]
          request_cookies
          []
          
          response_headers
          0 of 0
          array:5 [ "content-type" => array:1 [ 0 => "text/html; charset=UTF-8" ] "cache-control" => array:1 [ 0 => "no-cache, private" ] "date" => array:1 [ 0 => "Mon, 14 Apr 2025 04:22:12 GMT" ] "set-cookie" => array:2 [ 0 => "XSRF-TOKEN=eyJpdiI6InJURTkxd05QVldFVjBDMXFQSG14dEE9PSIsInZhbHVlIjoidUdHd0lnUEQyRy9nL2lsUm9XWVVWaGN1bytYL3ZtTEEzNlE0KzM3WDlkcGFjTVNweUM1aEoyb0R2NkI0YnduVElEOS9jRlExM1dQcjZCZzdpZDdTWHAyUkVLNjNQZWRBQ2IwT0FzY0VEUVRvT3RWZlBIN2ZNaStDQW9JeHp0SFEiLCJtYWMiOiI2OGIwZmQ2N2RjY2NkN2I5ODZkN2YwNDlhNGRmN2FlNjcwYmQ3ZDY2ODU1OWRhZTE2YjE3OWQ1OWNiNmJkZjczIiwidGFnIjoiIn0%3D; expires=Mon, 14 Apr 2025 06:22:12 GMT; Max-Age=7200; path=/; domain=.24houranswers.com; samesite=laxXSRF-TOKEN=eyJpdiI6InJURTkxd05QVldFVjBDMXFQSG14dEE9PSIsInZhbHVlIjoidUdHd0lnUEQyRy9nL2lsUm9XWVVWaGN1bytYL3ZtTEEzNlE0KzM3WDlkcGFjTVNweUM1aEoyb0R2NkI0YnduVElEOS9jR" 1 => "24houranswers_session=eyJpdiI6Ii9HVmtDUEFsOUNpMlVXNG1vVzlsSEE9PSIsInZhbHVlIjoiRTRXZ0twaWV6dVE4NHU2VXNKb1JoZWw1YXpwRzkrK2p6MWpJRGg4VE5JWlVtQ2R3OE1FM2FIdmdJQVNpNXNrQ0l6QWsreVhIMUt5TUdWcWdTblYwRXNPZmcrY2NjMlc0ancydXYyL2VicjVDMysyNWNZWVc4WE5Kb2c0T08vdVAiLCJtYWMiOiJlZjc0NWY5OTllOWM0ZTU0N2JhMGQ0Nzg5NTQ0MzU2ZWVjNWNkMjkyOGFiOTg2MDU5NWI3MTk0N2JmMDg3ODUxIiwidGFnIjoiIn0%3D; expires=Mon, 14 Apr 2025 06:22:12 GMT; Max-Age=7200; path=/; domain=.24houranswers.com; httponly; samesite=lax24houranswers_session=eyJpdiI6Ii9HVmtDUEFsOUNpMlVXNG1vVzlsSEE9PSIsInZhbHVlIjoiRTRXZ0twaWV6dVE4NHU2VXNKb1JoZWw1YXpwRzkrK2p6MWpJRGg4VE5JWlVtQ2R3OE1FM2FIdmdJQVNpNX" ] "Set-Cookie" => array:2 [ 0 => "XSRF-TOKEN=eyJpdiI6InJURTkxd05QVldFVjBDMXFQSG14dEE9PSIsInZhbHVlIjoidUdHd0lnUEQyRy9nL2lsUm9XWVVWaGN1bytYL3ZtTEEzNlE0KzM3WDlkcGFjTVNweUM1aEoyb0R2NkI0YnduVElEOS9jRlExM1dQcjZCZzdpZDdTWHAyUkVLNjNQZWRBQ2IwT0FzY0VEUVRvT3RWZlBIN2ZNaStDQW9JeHp0SFEiLCJtYWMiOiI2OGIwZmQ2N2RjY2NkN2I5ODZkN2YwNDlhNGRmN2FlNjcwYmQ3ZDY2ODU1OWRhZTE2YjE3OWQ1OWNiNmJkZjczIiwidGFnIjoiIn0%3D; expires=Mon, 14-Apr-2025 06:22:12 GMT; domain=.24houranswers.com; path=/XSRF-TOKEN=eyJpdiI6InJURTkxd05QVldFVjBDMXFQSG14dEE9PSIsInZhbHVlIjoidUdHd0lnUEQyRy9nL2lsUm9XWVVWaGN1bytYL3ZtTEEzNlE0KzM3WDlkcGFjTVNweUM1aEoyb0R2NkI0YnduVElEOS9jR" 1 => "24houranswers_session=eyJpdiI6Ii9HVmtDUEFsOUNpMlVXNG1vVzlsSEE9PSIsInZhbHVlIjoiRTRXZ0twaWV6dVE4NHU2VXNKb1JoZWw1YXpwRzkrK2p6MWpJRGg4VE5JWlVtQ2R3OE1FM2FIdmdJQVNpNXNrQ0l6QWsreVhIMUt5TUdWcWdTblYwRXNPZmcrY2NjMlc0ancydXYyL2VicjVDMysyNWNZWVc4WE5Kb2c0T08vdVAiLCJtYWMiOiJlZjc0NWY5OTllOWM0ZTU0N2JhMGQ0Nzg5NTQ0MzU2ZWVjNWNkMjkyOGFiOTg2MDU5NWI3MTk0N2JmMDg3ODUxIiwidGFnIjoiIn0%3D; expires=Mon, 14-Apr-2025 06:22:12 GMT; domain=.24houranswers.com; path=/; httponly24houranswers_session=eyJpdiI6Ii9HVmtDUEFsOUNpMlVXNG1vVzlsSEE9PSIsInZhbHVlIjoiRTRXZ0twaWV6dVE4NHU2VXNKb1JoZWw1YXpwRzkrK2p6MWpJRGg4VE5JWlVtQ2R3OE1FM2FIdmdJQVNpNX" ] ]
          session_attributes
          0 of 0
          array:6 [ "_token" => "jvAteRegpFLxdSG4mXy2Doxw3IRxHOrlhU9O2Uod" "utm_source" => "direct" "redirectUrl" => "/college-homework-library/Literature/Literature-Analysis/2982" "_previous" => array:1 [ "url" => "https://staging.dev.24houranswers.com/college-homework-library/Literature/Literature-Analysis/2982" ] "_flash" => array:2 [ "old" => [] "new" => [] ] "PHPDEBUGBAR_STACK_DATA" => [] ]