Question
In his essay "Knowledge and Skepticism," Nozick shows that skeptical possibilities violate his conditions and so, on his theory, we cannot know that skeptical possibilities aren’t realized. (You cannot know that you are not in the matrix, but in the movie some characters do know this, so is the movie incoherent?)
Skepticism, the view that little or nothing is known, does not follow unless we assume the principle of closure: you know whatever you correctly infer from what you know.
The inability to know one is not in the matrix does not preempt ordinary knowledge if one can have ordinary knowledge without being able to know what is correctly inferable from ordinary knowledge.
Nozick protects ordinary knowledge against skepticism by rejecting the closure principle.
On his theory, closure fails because propositions that satisfy his subjunctive conditions for knowing have logical consequences that do not. We may now entertain several possibilities:

1. Nozick is right about what it takes to know and closure fails. Although I do not know that I am not being manipulated into believing p falsely, nevertheless (amazingly) I do know P.

2. Nozick is wrong about what knowledge is and closure holds. Since I do not know that I am not manipulated I can’t know anything whose truth depends on my not being manipulated. A very general skepticism then holds.

3. Nozick is wrong about knowledge and closure holds, but I can know that I am not manipulated, and so ordinary knowledge is unthreatened. Even though things would seem the same if I were manipulated, still I can know that I’m not. Skepticism is false.

4. Nozick is right about knowledge but wrong about closure, because the belief that one is not a victim of manipulation satisfies Nozick’s conditions for knowledge after all.

In your paper on Nozick pick an option above (or another if you think of one you prefer) and defend it.
Here is one thought to help you select.
The entire discussion of skepticism and closure ignores the method or process that produces the belief whose knowability is at issue.
The method was earlier said to be crucial to whether one knows, but subsequently is neglected.
Does reintroducing it help?
Does how one forms the belief that one is not a victim matter to whether this belief satisfies Nozick’s conditions for knowledge?
Solution Preview

These solutions may offer step-by-step problem-solving explanations or good writing examples that include modern styles of formatting and construction of bibliographies out of text citations and references.
Students may use these solutions for personal skill-building and practice.
Unethical use is strictly forbidden.

In his essay entitled "Knowledge and Skepticism" Nozick rejects the theory of closure and holds that "knowledge is not simply justified belief" (p. 3). Closure holds that inference about knowledge can be made from already known facts. In this account of knowledge, belief about what is true can be deductible logically from what is already known about one's surroundings and the world.
This is only a preview of the solution.
Please use the purchase button to see the entire solution.
By purchasing this solution you'll be able to access the following files:
Solution.docx
Purchase Solution
$2.00
Google Pay
Amazon
Paypal
Mastercard
Visacard
Discover
Amex
View Available Philosophy Tutors 529 tutors matched
Ionut
(ionut)
Hi! MSc Applied Informatics & Computer Science Engineer. Practical experience in many CS & IT branches.Research work & homework
5/5 (5,654+ sessions)
2 hours avg response
Leo
(Leo)
Hi! I have been a professor in New York and taught in a math department and in an applied math department.
4.9/5 (5,652+ sessions)
2 hours avg response
Pranay
(math1983)
Ph.D. in mathematics and working as an Assistant Professor in University. I can provide help in mathematics, statistics and allied areas.
4.6/5 (5,512+ sessions)
1 hour avg response

Similar Homework Solutions

8.1.0PHP Version450msRequest Duration45MBMemory UsageGET college-homework-library/{category}/{subject}/{id}Route
    • Booting (293ms)time
    • Application (157ms)time
    • 1 x Booting (65.06%)
      293ms
      1 x Application (34.94%)
      157ms
      • Illuminate\Routing\Events\Routing (876μs)
      • Illuminate\Routing\Events\RouteMatched (380μs)
      • Illuminate\Foundation\Events\LocaleUpdated (1.93ms)
      • eloquent.booting: App\Models\HomeworkLibrary\HomeworkLibrary (175μs)
      • eloquent.booted: App\Models\HomeworkLibrary\HomeworkLibrary (141μs)
      • Illuminate\Database\Events\ConnectionEstablished (692μs)
      • Illuminate\Database\Events\StatementPrepared (13.56ms)
      • Illuminate\Database\Events\QueryExecuted (1.64ms)
      • eloquent.retrieved: App\Models\HomeworkLibrary\HomeworkLibrary (103μs)
      • eloquent.booting: App\Models\Subject (69μs)
      • eloquent.booted: App\Models\Subject (227μs)
      • Illuminate\Database\Events\StatementPrepared (1.48ms)
      • Illuminate\Database\Events\QueryExecuted (1.95ms)
      • eloquent.retrieved: App\Models\Subject (128μs)
      • eloquent.booting: App\Models\HomeworkLibrary\HomeworkLibraryFile (98μs)
      • eloquent.booted: App\Models\HomeworkLibrary\HomeworkLibraryFile (40μs)
      • Illuminate\Database\Events\StatementPrepared (696μs)
      • Illuminate\Database\Events\QueryExecuted (4ms)
      • eloquent.retrieved: App\Models\HomeworkLibrary\HomeworkLibraryFile (108μs)
      • eloquent.retrieved: App\Models\HomeworkLibrary\HomeworkLibraryFile (17μs)
      • eloquent.retrieved: App\Models\HomeworkLibrary\HomeworkLibraryFile (8μs)
      • eloquent.booting: App\Models\SubjectCat (574μs)
      • eloquent.booted: App\Models\SubjectCat (61μs)
      • Illuminate\Database\Events\StatementPrepared (824μs)
      • Illuminate\Database\Events\QueryExecuted (2.13ms)
      • eloquent.retrieved: App\Models\SubjectCat (157μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (14.82ms)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheMissed (308μs)
      • Illuminate\Database\Events\StatementPrepared (1.11ms)
      • Illuminate\Database\Events\QueryExecuted (3.62ms)
      • eloquent.retrieved: App\Models\HomeworkLibrary\HomeworkLibrary (101μs)
      • eloquent.retrieved: App\Models\HomeworkLibrary\HomeworkLibrary (17μs)
      • eloquent.retrieved: App\Models\HomeworkLibrary\HomeworkLibrary (8μs)
      • eloquent.retrieved: App\Models\HomeworkLibrary\HomeworkLibrary (8μs)
      • eloquent.retrieved: App\Models\HomeworkLibrary\HomeworkLibrary (9μs)
      • eloquent.retrieved: App\Models\HomeworkLibrary\HomeworkLibrary (6μs)
      • Illuminate\Database\Events\StatementPrepared (870μs)
      • Illuminate\Database\Events\QueryExecuted (889μs)
      • eloquent.retrieved: App\Models\Subject (100μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\KeyWritten (770μs)
      • Illuminate\Database\Events\StatementPrepared (2.5ms)
      • Illuminate\Database\Events\QueryExecuted (1.3ms)
      • Illuminate\Database\Events\StatementPrepared (788μs)
      • Illuminate\Database\Events\QueryExecuted (1.16ms)
      • Illuminate\Database\Events\StatementPrepared (721μs)
      • Illuminate\Database\Events\QueryExecuted (1.06ms)
      • eloquent.retrieved: App\Models\HomeworkLibrary\HomeworkLibraryFile (51μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (784μs)
      • creating: homework.show (298μs)
      • composing: homework.show (121μs)
      • creating: components.breadcrumbs (279μs)
      • composing: components.breadcrumbs (356μs)
      • Illuminate\Database\Events\StatementPrepared (1.33ms)
      • Illuminate\Database\Events\QueryExecuted (1.06ms)
      • eloquent.retrieved: App\Models\SubjectCat (80μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheMissed (4.84ms)
      • Illuminate\Database\Events\StatementPrepared (669μs)
      • Illuminate\Database\Events\QueryExecuted (912μs)
      • eloquent.retrieved: App\Models\SubjectCat (73μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\KeyWritten (348μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (222μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (157μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (112μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (130μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (111μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (128μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (140μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (134μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (108μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (119μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (379μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (165μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (110μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheMissed (222μs)
      • Illuminate\Database\Events\StatementPrepared (699μs)
      • Illuminate\Database\Events\QueryExecuted (1.26ms)
      • eloquent.retrieved: App\Models\SubjectCat (93μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\KeyWritten (462μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (1.61ms)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (285μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (253μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (217μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (215μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (233μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (193μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheMissed (291μs)
      • Illuminate\Database\Events\StatementPrepared (914μs)
      • Illuminate\Database\Events\QueryExecuted (1.14ms)
      • eloquent.retrieved: App\Models\SubjectCat (85μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\KeyWritten (346μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (1.36ms)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (245μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (149μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (144μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (118μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (204μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (168μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (150μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (120μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (133μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (131μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (191μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (128μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (150μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (110μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (122μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (104μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (119μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (104μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (118μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (107μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (130μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (114μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (125μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (107μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (152μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (118μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (153μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (120μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (154μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (118μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheMissed (225μs)
      • Illuminate\Database\Events\StatementPrepared (819μs)
      • Illuminate\Database\Events\QueryExecuted (1.31ms)
      • eloquent.retrieved: App\Models\SubjectCat (71μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\KeyWritten (1.5ms)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (263μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (184μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (152μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (174μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (116μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (133μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (154μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (163μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (123μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (429μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (136μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (141μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (120μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (143μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (123μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (235μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (152μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (142μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (116μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (131μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (119μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (150μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (122μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (133μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (115μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (134μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (117μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (129μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (117μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (131μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (115μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (129μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (118μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (134μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (116μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (131μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (111μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (187μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (134μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheMissed (142μs)
      • Illuminate\Database\Events\StatementPrepared (776μs)
      • Illuminate\Database\Events\QueryExecuted (854μs)
      • eloquent.retrieved: App\Models\SubjectCat (75μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\KeyWritten (363μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (224μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (160μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (110μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (122μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (112μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (136μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (126μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheMissed (209μs)
      • Illuminate\Database\Events\StatementPrepared (638μs)
      • Illuminate\Database\Events\QueryExecuted (897μs)
      • eloquent.retrieved: App\Models\SubjectCat (74μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\KeyWritten (279μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (187μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (157μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (110μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (150μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (117μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (131μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (111μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (156μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (108μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (133μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (113μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (599μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (118μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (126μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (372μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (170μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (108μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (116μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (97μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (115μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (121μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (117μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (119μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (116μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (100μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (120μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (103μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (142μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (112μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheMissed (138μs)
      • Illuminate\Database\Events\StatementPrepared (771μs)
      • Illuminate\Database\Events\QueryExecuted (984μs)
      • eloquent.retrieved: App\Models\SubjectCat (79μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\KeyWritten (437μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (1.37ms)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (214μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (124μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (129μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (123μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (124μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (124μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (147μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (109μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (129μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (103μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (118μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (119μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (128μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (120μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (120μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (102μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (117μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (99μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (281μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (144μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (125μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (98μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (114μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (97μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (123μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (107μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (117μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (100μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (143μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (113μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (126μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (108μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (121μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (102μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (115μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (100μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (115μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (100μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (116μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (98μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (137μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (109μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (117μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (101μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (115μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (105μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (119μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (106μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (136μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (115μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (125μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (109μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (206μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (137μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (129μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (106μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (133μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (116μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (120μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (101μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (122μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (107μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheMissed (216μs)
      • Illuminate\Database\Events\StatementPrepared (1.24ms)
      • Illuminate\Database\Events\QueryExecuted (1.07ms)
      • eloquent.retrieved: App\Models\SubjectCat (87μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\KeyWritten (455μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (241μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (177μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (127μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (162μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (120μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (135μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (146μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (129μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (102μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (119μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (110μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (118μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (109μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (119μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (99μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (155μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (108μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (661μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (113μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (127μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (106μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (121μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (109μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (122μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (353μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (136μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (101μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (123μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (101μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (141μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (111μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (117μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (104μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (119μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (102μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (146μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (113μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (133μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (102μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (118μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (105μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (116μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (104μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (118μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (100μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (115μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (103μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (118μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (101μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (116μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (103μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (118μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (100μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (118μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (105μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (144μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (111μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (236μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (116μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (118μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (100μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (132μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (100μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (123μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (108μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (117μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (101μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (133μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (102μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (144μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (130μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (136μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (109μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (125μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (119μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (123μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (103μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (127μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (105μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (134μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (105μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (121μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (99μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (120μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (105μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (144μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (110μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (125μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (107μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheMissed (281μs)
      • Illuminate\Database\Events\StatementPrepared (865μs)
      • Illuminate\Database\Events\QueryExecuted (1.04ms)
      • eloquent.retrieved: App\Models\SubjectCat (82μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\KeyWritten (360μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (206μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (165μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (114μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (126μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (107μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (166μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (125μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (138μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (103μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (120μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (103μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (177μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (126μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (130μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (103μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (115μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (99μs)
      • creating: site.layouts.app (381μs)
      • composing: site.layouts.app (17μs)
      • creating: components.canonical (411μs)
      • composing: components.canonical (79μs)
      • creating: components.open-graph (147μs)
      • composing: components.open-graph (51μs)
      • creating: site.headers.header (215μs)
      • composing: site.headers.header (49μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (1.86ms)
      • creating: components.footer (199μs)
      • composing: components.footer (95μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (690μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheMissed (303μs)
      • Illuminate\Database\Events\StatementPrepared (778μs)
      • Illuminate\Database\Events\QueryExecuted (1.27ms)
      • eloquent.retrieved: App\Models\SubjectCat (77μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\KeyWritten (309μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (286μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (600μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (165μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (156μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (161μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (206μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (219μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (137μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (271μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (222μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (217μs)
      • Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (199μs)
      • creating: components.forms.contact-us (293μs)
      • composing: components.forms.contact-us (219μs)
      • creating: components.forms.get-started (235μs)
      • composing: components.forms.get-started (95μs)
      • creating: components.forms.free-tool-download (152μs)
      • composing: components.forms.free-tool-download (85μs)
      • creating: components.forms.claim-free-worksheet (152μs)
      • composing: components.forms.claim-free-worksheet (86μs)
      • creating: components.forms.tutor-subscription-waitlist (149μs)
      • composing: components.forms.tutor-subscription-waitlist (249μs)
      • creating: components.forms.tutor-subscription-join (160μs)
      • composing: components.forms.tutor-subscription-join (82μs)
      • creating: components.forms.tutor-support (149μs)
      • composing: components.forms.tutor-support (78μs)
      • 311 x Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheHit (14.5%)
        65.28ms
        20 x Illuminate\Database\Events\StatementPrepared (7.12%)
        32.05ms
        20 x Illuminate\Database\Events\QueryExecuted (6.56%)
        29.54ms
        11 x Illuminate\Cache\Events\CacheMissed (1.59%)
        7.17ms
        11 x Illuminate\Cache\Events\KeyWritten (1.25%)
        5.63ms
        1 x Illuminate\Foundation\Events\LocaleUpdated (0.43%)
        1.93ms
        12 x eloquent.retrieved: App\Models\SubjectCat (0.23%)
        1.03ms
        1 x Illuminate\Routing\Events\Routing (0.19%)
        876μs
        1 x Illuminate\Database\Events\ConnectionEstablished (0.15%)
        692μs
        1 x eloquent.booting: App\Models\SubjectCat (0.13%)
        574μs
        1 x creating: components.canonical (0.09%)
        411μs
        1 x creating: site.layouts.app (0.08%)
        381μs
        1 x Illuminate\Routing\Events\RouteMatched (0.08%)
        380μs
        1 x composing: components.breadcrumbs (0.08%)
        356μs
        1 x creating: homework.show (0.07%)
        298μs
        1 x creating: components.forms.contact-us (0.07%)
        293μs
        1 x creating: components.breadcrumbs (0.06%)
        279μs
        7 x eloquent.retrieved: App\Models\HomeworkLibrary\HomeworkLibrary (0.06%)
        252μs
        1 x composing: components.forms.tutor-subscription-waitlist (0.06%)
        249μs
        1 x creating: components.forms.get-started (0.05%)
        235μs
        2 x eloquent.retrieved: App\Models\Subject (0.05%)
        228μs
        1 x eloquent.booted: App\Models\Subject (0.05%)
        227μs
        1 x composing: components.forms.contact-us (0.05%)
        219μs
        1 x creating: site.headers.header (0.05%)
        215μs
        1 x creating: components.footer (0.04%)
        199μs
        4 x eloquent.retrieved: App\Models\HomeworkLibrary\HomeworkLibraryFile (0.04%)
        184μs
        1 x eloquent.booting: App\Models\HomeworkLibrary\HomeworkLibrary (0.04%)
        175μs
        1 x creating: components.forms.tutor-subscription-join (0.04%)
        160μs
        1 x creating: components.forms.free-tool-download (0.03%)
        152μs
        1 x creating: components.forms.claim-free-worksheet (0.03%)
        152μs
        1 x creating: components.forms.tutor-subscription-waitlist (0.03%)
        149μs
        1 x creating: components.forms.tutor-support (0.03%)
        149μs
        1 x creating: components.open-graph (0.03%)
        147μs
        1 x eloquent.booted: App\Models\HomeworkLibrary\HomeworkLibrary (0.03%)
        141μs
        1 x composing: homework.show (0.03%)
        121μs
        1 x eloquent.booting: App\Models\HomeworkLibrary\HomeworkLibraryFile (0.02%)
        98μs
        1 x composing: components.footer (0.02%)
        95μs
        1 x composing: components.forms.get-started (0.02%)
        95μs
        1 x composing: components.forms.claim-free-worksheet (0.02%)
        86μs
        1 x composing: components.forms.free-tool-download (0.02%)
        85μs
        1 x composing: components.forms.tutor-subscription-join (0.02%)
        82μs
        1 x composing: components.canonical (0.02%)
        79μs
        1 x composing: components.forms.tutor-support (0.02%)
        78μs
        1 x eloquent.booting: App\Models\Subject (0.02%)
        69μs
        1 x eloquent.booted: App\Models\SubjectCat (0.01%)
        61μs
        1 x composing: components.open-graph (0.01%)
        51μs
        1 x composing: site.headers.header (0.01%)
        49μs
        1 x eloquent.booted: App\Models\HomeworkLibrary\HomeworkLibraryFile (0.01%)
        40μs
        1 x composing: site.layouts.app (0%)
        17μs
      14 templates were rendered
      • 1x homework.showshow.blade.phpblade
      • 1x components.breadcrumbsbreadcrumbs.blade.phpblade
      • 1x site.layouts.appapp.blade.phpblade
      • 1x components.canonicalcanonical.blade.phpblade
      • 1x components.open-graphopen-graph.blade.phpblade
      • 1x site.headers.headerheader.blade.phpblade
      • 1x components.footerfooter.blade.phpblade
      • 1x components.forms.contact-uscontact-us.blade.phpblade
      • 1x components.forms.get-startedget-started.blade.phpblade
      • 1x components.forms.free-tool-downloadfree-tool-download.blade.phpblade
      • 1x components.forms.claim-free-worksheetclaim-free-worksheet.blade.phpblade
      • 1x components.forms.tutor-subscription-waitlisttutor-subscription-waitlist.blade.phpblade
      • 1x components.forms.tutor-subscription-jointutor-subscription-join.blade.phpblade
      • 1x components.forms.tutor-supporttutor-support.blade.phpblade
      uri
      GET college-homework-library/{category}/{subject}/{id}
      middleware
      web, utm.parameters
      controller
      App\Http\Controllers\HomeworkLibraryController@show
      namespace
      where
      as
      homework.show
      file
      app/Http/Controllers/HomeworkLibraryController.php:79-176
      20 statements were executed, 4 of which were duplicates, 16 unique. Show only duplicated46.15ms
      • Connection Establishedtwenty4_siteHomeworkLibraryController.php#91
        Backtrace
        • 13. app/Http/Controllers/HomeworkLibraryController.php:91
        • 14. vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Routing/Controller.php:54
        • 15. vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Routing/ControllerDispatcher.php:43
        • 16. vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Routing/Route.php:260
        • 17. vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Routing/Route.php:205
      • select * from `solutionslibrary` where `status` = 'published' and `price` > 0 and `solutionslibrary`.`id` = '6121' limit 1
        14.06mstwenty4_siteHomeworkLibraryController.php#97
        Bindings
        • 0: published
        • 1: 0
        • 2: 6121
        Backtrace
        • 16. app/Http/Controllers/HomeworkLibraryController.php:97
        • 17. vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Routing/Controller.php:54
        • 18. vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Routing/ControllerDispatcher.php:43
        • 19. vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Routing/Route.php:260
        • 20. vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Routing/Route.php:205
      • select * from `subjects` where `subjects`.`id` in (276)
        1.83mstwenty4_siteHomeworkLibraryController.php#97
        Backtrace
        • 21. app/Http/Controllers/HomeworkLibraryController.php:97
        • 22. vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Routing/Controller.php:54
        • 23. vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Routing/ControllerDispatcher.php:43
        • 24. vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Routing/Route.php:260
        • 25. vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Routing/Route.php:205
      • select * from `solutionslibrary_files` where `solutionslibrary_files`.`solutionlib_id` in (6121)
        4.04mstwenty4_siteHomeworkLibraryController.php#97
        Backtrace
        • 21. app/Http/Controllers/HomeworkLibraryController.php:97
        • 22. vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Routing/Controller.php:54
        • 23. vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Routing/ControllerDispatcher.php:43
        • 24. vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Routing/Route.php:260
        • 25. vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Routing/Route.php:205
      • select * from `subject_cats` where `subject_cats`.`id` = 23 limit 1
        1.99mstwenty4_siteHomeworkLibrary.php#201
        Bindings
        • 0: 23
        Backtrace
        • 20. app/Models/HomeworkLibrary/HomeworkLibrary.php:201
        • 26. app/Http/Controllers/HomeworkLibraryController.php:105
        • 27. vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Routing/Controller.php:54
        • 28. vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Routing/ControllerDispatcher.php:43
        • 29. vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Routing/Route.php:260
      • select * from `solutionslibrary` where `id` <> 6121 and `subject` = 276 and `status` = 'published' and `price` > 0 order by RAND() limit 6
        3.92mstwenty4_siteHomeworkLibraryRepository.php#30
        Bindings
        • 0: 6121
        • 1: 276
        • 2: published
        • 3: 0
        Backtrace
        • 14. app/Repositories/HomeworkLibraryRepository.php:30
        • 15. vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Cache/Repository.php:397
        • 16. vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Cache/CacheManager.php:419
        • 18. app/Repositories/HomeworkLibraryRepository.php:39
        • 19. app/Http/Controllers/HomeworkLibraryController.php:139
      • select * from `subjects` where `subjects`.`id` in (276)
        1.2mstwenty4_siteHomeworkLibraryRepository.php#30
        Backtrace
        • 19. app/Repositories/HomeworkLibraryRepository.php:30
        • 20. vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Cache/Repository.php:397
        • 21. vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Cache/CacheManager.php:419
        • 23. app/Repositories/HomeworkLibraryRepository.php:39
        • 24. app/Http/Controllers/HomeworkLibraryController.php:139
      • select * from `solutionslibrary_files` where `solutionslibrary_files`.`solutionlib_id` = 6121 and `solutionslibrary_files`.`solutionlib_id` is not null and `publish` = 'question' order by `order` asc, `id` asc
        1.97mstwenty4_siteHomeworkLibrary.php#260
        Bindings
        • 0: 6121
        • 1: question
        Backtrace
        • 15. app/Models/HomeworkLibrary/HomeworkLibrary.php:260
        • 16. app/Transformers/HomeworkLibrary/HomeworkLibraryTransformer.php:58
        • 19. vendor/league/fractal/src/TransformerAbstract.php:128
        • 20. vendor/league/fractal/src/TransformerAbstract.php:107
        • 21. vendor/league/fractal/src/Scope.php:383
      • select * from `solutionslibrary_files` where `solutionslibrary_files`.`solutionlib_id` = 6121 and `solutionslibrary_files`.`solutionlib_id` is not null and `publish` = 'teaser' order by `order` asc, `id` asc
        1.31mstwenty4_siteHomeworkLibrary.php#260
        Bindings
        • 0: 6121
        • 1: teaser
        Backtrace
        • 15. app/Models/HomeworkLibrary/HomeworkLibrary.php:260
        • 16. app/Transformers/HomeworkLibrary/HomeworkLibraryTransformer.php:69
        • 19. vendor/league/fractal/src/TransformerAbstract.php:128
        • 20. vendor/league/fractal/src/TransformerAbstract.php:107
        • 21. vendor/league/fractal/src/Scope.php:383
      • select * from `solutionslibrary_files` where `solutionslibrary_files`.`solutionlib_id` = 6121 and `solutionslibrary_files`.`solutionlib_id` is not null and `publish` = 'solution' order by `order` asc, `id` asc
        1.23mstwenty4_siteHomeworkLibrary.php#260
        Bindings
        • 0: 6121
        • 1: solution
        Backtrace
        • 15. app/Models/HomeworkLibrary/HomeworkLibrary.php:260
        • 16. app/Transformers/HomeworkLibrary/HomeworkLibraryTransformer.php:80
        • 19. vendor/league/fractal/src/TransformerAbstract.php:128
        • 20. vendor/league/fractal/src/TransformerAbstract.php:107
        • 21. vendor/league/fractal/src/Scope.php:383
      • select * from `subject_cats` where `subject_cats`.`id` = 23 limit 1
        1.33mstwenty4_siteHomeworkLibrary.php#201
        Bindings
        • 0: 23
        Backtrace
        • 20. app/Models/HomeworkLibrary/HomeworkLibrary.php:201
        • 32. vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Filesystem/Filesystem.php:110
        • 33. vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/View/Engines/PhpEngine.php:58
        • 34. vendor/livewire/livewire/src/ComponentConcerns/RendersLivewireComponents.php:69
        • 35. vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/View/Engines/CompilerEngine.php:70
      • select * from `subject_cats` where `subject_cats`.`id` = 1 limit 1
        1.02mstwenty4_siteSubject.php#100
        Bindings
        • 0: 1
        Backtrace
        • 18. app/Models/Subject.php:100
        • 19. vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Cache/Repository.php:397
        • 20. vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Cache/CacheManager.php:419
        • 22. app/Models/Subject.php:101
        • 34. vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Filesystem/Filesystem.php:110
      • select * from `subject_cats` where `subject_cats`.`id` = 3 limit 1
        1.32mstwenty4_siteSubject.php#100
        Bindings
        • 0: 3
        Backtrace
        • 18. app/Models/Subject.php:100
        • 19. vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Cache/Repository.php:397
        • 20. vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Cache/CacheManager.php:419
        • 22. app/Models/Subject.php:101
        • 34. vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Filesystem/Filesystem.php:110
      • select * from `subject_cats` where `subject_cats`.`id` = 4 limit 1
        1.43mstwenty4_siteSubject.php#100
        Bindings
        • 0: 4
        Backtrace
        • 18. app/Models/Subject.php:100
        • 19. vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Cache/Repository.php:397
        • 20. vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Cache/CacheManager.php:419
        • 22. app/Models/Subject.php:101
        • 34. vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Filesystem/Filesystem.php:110
      • select * from `subject_cats` where `subject_cats`.`id` = 10 limit 1
        1.58mstwenty4_siteSubject.php#100
        Bindings
        • 0: 10
        Backtrace
        • 18. app/Models/Subject.php:100
        • 19. vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Cache/Repository.php:397
        • 20. vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Cache/CacheManager.php:419
        • 22. app/Models/Subject.php:101
        • 34. vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Filesystem/Filesystem.php:110
      • select * from `subject_cats` where `subject_cats`.`id` = 33 limit 1
        1.17mstwenty4_siteSubject.php#100
        Bindings
        • 0: 33
        Backtrace
        • 18. app/Models/Subject.php:100
        • 19. vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Cache/Repository.php:397
        • 20. vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Cache/CacheManager.php:419
        • 22. app/Models/Subject.php:101
        • 34. vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Filesystem/Filesystem.php:110
      • select * from `subject_cats` where `subject_cats`.`id` = 11 limit 1
        1.03mstwenty4_siteSubject.php#100
        Bindings
        • 0: 11
        Backtrace
        • 18. app/Models/Subject.php:100
        • 19. vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Cache/Repository.php:397
        • 20. vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Cache/CacheManager.php:419
        • 22. app/Models/Subject.php:101
        • 34. vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Filesystem/Filesystem.php:110
      • select * from `subject_cats` where `subject_cats`.`id` = 5 limit 1
        1.34mstwenty4_siteSubject.php#100
        Bindings
        • 0: 5
        Backtrace
        • 18. app/Models/Subject.php:100
        • 19. vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Cache/Repository.php:397
        • 20. vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Cache/CacheManager.php:419
        • 22. app/Models/Subject.php:101
        • 34. vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Filesystem/Filesystem.php:110
      • select * from `subject_cats` where `subject_cats`.`id` = 34 limit 1
        1.73mstwenty4_siteSubject.php#100
        Bindings
        • 0: 34
        Backtrace
        • 18. app/Models/Subject.php:100
        • 19. vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Cache/Repository.php:397
        • 20. vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Cache/CacheManager.php:419
        • 22. app/Models/Subject.php:101
        • 34. vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Filesystem/Filesystem.php:110
      • select * from `subject_cats` where `subject_cats`.`id` = 31 limit 1
        1.26mstwenty4_siteSubject.php#100
        Bindings
        • 0: 31
        Backtrace
        • 18. app/Models/Subject.php:100
        • 19. vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Cache/Repository.php:397
        • 20. vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Cache/CacheManager.php:419
        • 22. app/Models/Subject.php:101
        • 34. vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Filesystem/Filesystem.php:110
      • select * from `subject_cats` where `subject_cats`.`id` = 36 limit 1
        1.39mstwenty4_siteSubject.php#100
        Bindings
        • 0: 36
        Backtrace
        • 18. app/Models/Subject.php:100
        • 19. vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Cache/Repository.php:397
        • 20. vendor/laravel/framework/src/Illuminate/Cache/CacheManager.php:419
        • 22. app/Models/Subject.php:101
        • 28. view::components.footer:170
      App\Models\SubjectCat
      12SubjectCat.php
      App\Models\HomeworkLibrary\HomeworkLibrary
      7HomeworkLibrary.php
      App\Models\HomeworkLibrary\HomeworkLibraryFile
      4HomeworkLibraryFile.php
      App\Models\Subject
      2Subject.php
          _token
          Rb22P9sKH3sj6xq3BnH4e5hbwDtqLr87UH3XAEvv
          utm_source
          direct
          redirectUrl
          /college-homework-library/Philosophy/Philosophic-Logic/6121
          _previous
          array:1 [ "url" => "https://staging.dev.24houranswers.com/college-homework-library/Philosophy/Phil...
          _flash
          array:2 [ "old" => [] "new" => [] ]
          PHPDEBUGBAR_STACK_DATA
          []
          path_info
          /college-homework-library/Philosophy/Philosophic-Logic/6121
          status_code
          200
          
          status_text
          OK
          format
          html
          content_type
          text/html; charset=UTF-8
          request_query
          []
          
          request_request
          []
          
          request_headers
          0 of 0
          array:21 [ "priority" => array:1 [ 0 => "u=0, i" ] "accept-encoding" => array:1 [ 0 => "gzip, deflate, br, zstd" ] "sec-fetch-dest" => array:1 [ 0 => "document" ] "sec-fetch-user" => array:1 [ 0 => "?1" ] "sec-fetch-mode" => array:1 [ 0 => "navigate" ] "sec-fetch-site" => array:1 [ 0 => "none" ] "accept" => array:1 [ 0 => "text/html,application/xhtml+xml,application/xml;q=0.9,image/avif,image/webp,image/apng,*/*;q=0.8,application/signed-exchange;v=b3;q=0.7" ] "user-agent" => array:1 [ 0 => "Mozilla/5.0 AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko; compatible; ClaudeBot/1.0; +claudebot@anthropic.com)" ] "upgrade-insecure-requests" => array:1 [ 0 => "1" ] "sec-ch-ua-platform" => array:1 [ 0 => ""Windows"" ] "sec-ch-ua-mobile" => array:1 [ 0 => "?0" ] "sec-ch-ua" => array:1 [ 0 => ""HeadlessChrome";v="129", "Not=A?Brand";v="8", "Chromium";v="129"" ] "cache-control" => array:1 [ 0 => "no-cache" ] "pragma" => array:1 [ 0 => "no-cache" ] "x-amzn-trace-id" => array:1 [ 0 => "Root=1-68090c73-78a7c5bb0ed2d5b474ceee7a" ] "host" => array:1 [ 0 => "staging.dev.24houranswers.com" ] "x-forwarded-port" => array:1 [ 0 => "443" ] "x-forwarded-proto" => array:1 [ 0 => "https" ] "x-forwarded-for" => array:1 [ 0 => "18.216.17.239" ] "content-length" => array:1 [ 0 => "" ] "content-type" => array:1 [ 0 => "" ] ]
          request_cookies
          []
          
          response_headers
          0 of 0
          array:5 [ "content-type" => array:1 [ 0 => "text/html; charset=UTF-8" ] "cache-control" => array:1 [ 0 => "no-cache, private" ] "date" => array:1 [ 0 => "Wed, 23 Apr 2025 15:51:15 GMT" ] "set-cookie" => array:2 [ 0 => "XSRF-TOKEN=eyJpdiI6ImdqTzc4UlQ1REpmY0dVSXBwUXptL0E9PSIsInZhbHVlIjoiZG11bHdUVW45TDBnc2xTUlVXb2x0R2tIcFpleWw0RGY2Z2NQTHp0SVB0aTljVS9xYXlIaDRiam1jbHlIaHlCanhaSFlveVQ4d1Z4cElUaVhPQ2tyMG9LS2xjaHFzNDdudi9CeTBVQ1ZZYktISEFla3ZrcytuNit0OXRHdlpCWG4iLCJtYWMiOiIyNmY1NDRiNjFjYjM1MjFlMDlkMGY1MTRlOWY4MTA0NTAwODY0NjQyMzJkOGJiNTUwNjU5Njg2N2M4YWI3OWJhIiwidGFnIjoiIn0%3D; expires=Wed, 23 Apr 2025 17:51:15 GMT; Max-Age=7200; path=/; domain=.24houranswers.com; samesite=laxXSRF-TOKEN=eyJpdiI6ImdqTzc4UlQ1REpmY0dVSXBwUXptL0E9PSIsInZhbHVlIjoiZG11bHdUVW45TDBnc2xTUlVXb2x0R2tIcFpleWw0RGY2Z2NQTHp0SVB0aTljVS9xYXlIaDRiam1jbHlIaHlCanhaSFlve" 1 => "24houranswers_session=eyJpdiI6IlJNSHRBTlNIWEdYRGVGTE5GMW12dlE9PSIsInZhbHVlIjoiVlVNWW5CMUNMdkQxQWRQWkNkZHZWRlByY2xSK0tRbjFQMmtkSUluRDdRbHN6V1crVFA2ak12b3JPRDhreGtTMkJ1Tm1KcTlwUk0wN0szOTk5YUtZSzdxQXNJTTk5TDRUbjcwV2xOeUNMSWJDeHVoSjdyNklXeGVUaGlQOWZuSjAiLCJtYWMiOiI4Yzk4ZmM5N2QzNmRkOTc0OTNhOTAwZGYwMWFiNjMxNzNlZDlmZmVmMTA1ZGMxNWU2YjkzMmQ4ZDdkYzQ4ZjA5IiwidGFnIjoiIn0%3D; expires=Wed, 23 Apr 2025 17:51:15 GMT; Max-Age=7200; path=/; domain=.24houranswers.com; httponly; samesite=lax24houranswers_session=eyJpdiI6IlJNSHRBTlNIWEdYRGVGTE5GMW12dlE9PSIsInZhbHVlIjoiVlVNWW5CMUNMdkQxQWRQWkNkZHZWRlByY2xSK0tRbjFQMmtkSUluRDdRbHN6V1crVFA2ak12b3JPRDhreG" ] "Set-Cookie" => array:2 [ 0 => "XSRF-TOKEN=eyJpdiI6ImdqTzc4UlQ1REpmY0dVSXBwUXptL0E9PSIsInZhbHVlIjoiZG11bHdUVW45TDBnc2xTUlVXb2x0R2tIcFpleWw0RGY2Z2NQTHp0SVB0aTljVS9xYXlIaDRiam1jbHlIaHlCanhaSFlveVQ4d1Z4cElUaVhPQ2tyMG9LS2xjaHFzNDdudi9CeTBVQ1ZZYktISEFla3ZrcytuNit0OXRHdlpCWG4iLCJtYWMiOiIyNmY1NDRiNjFjYjM1MjFlMDlkMGY1MTRlOWY4MTA0NTAwODY0NjQyMzJkOGJiNTUwNjU5Njg2N2M4YWI3OWJhIiwidGFnIjoiIn0%3D; expires=Wed, 23-Apr-2025 17:51:15 GMT; domain=.24houranswers.com; path=/XSRF-TOKEN=eyJpdiI6ImdqTzc4UlQ1REpmY0dVSXBwUXptL0E9PSIsInZhbHVlIjoiZG11bHdUVW45TDBnc2xTUlVXb2x0R2tIcFpleWw0RGY2Z2NQTHp0SVB0aTljVS9xYXlIaDRiam1jbHlIaHlCanhaSFlve" 1 => "24houranswers_session=eyJpdiI6IlJNSHRBTlNIWEdYRGVGTE5GMW12dlE9PSIsInZhbHVlIjoiVlVNWW5CMUNMdkQxQWRQWkNkZHZWRlByY2xSK0tRbjFQMmtkSUluRDdRbHN6V1crVFA2ak12b3JPRDhreGtTMkJ1Tm1KcTlwUk0wN0szOTk5YUtZSzdxQXNJTTk5TDRUbjcwV2xOeUNMSWJDeHVoSjdyNklXeGVUaGlQOWZuSjAiLCJtYWMiOiI4Yzk4ZmM5N2QzNmRkOTc0OTNhOTAwZGYwMWFiNjMxNzNlZDlmZmVmMTA1ZGMxNWU2YjkzMmQ4ZDdkYzQ4ZjA5IiwidGFnIjoiIn0%3D; expires=Wed, 23-Apr-2025 17:51:15 GMT; domain=.24houranswers.com; path=/; httponly24houranswers_session=eyJpdiI6IlJNSHRBTlNIWEdYRGVGTE5GMW12dlE9PSIsInZhbHVlIjoiVlVNWW5CMUNMdkQxQWRQWkNkZHZWRlByY2xSK0tRbjFQMmtkSUluRDdRbHN6V1crVFA2ak12b3JPRDhreG" ] ]
          session_attributes
          0 of 0
          array:6 [ "_token" => "Rb22P9sKH3sj6xq3BnH4e5hbwDtqLr87UH3XAEvv" "utm_source" => "direct" "redirectUrl" => "/college-homework-library/Philosophy/Philosophic-Logic/6121" "_previous" => array:1 [ "url" => "https://staging.dev.24houranswers.com/college-homework-library/Philosophy/Philosophic-Logic/6121" ] "_flash" => array:2 [ "old" => [] "new" => [] ] "PHPDEBUGBAR_STACK_DATA" => [] ]